Latina Lawyers

In the past few decades, a lot has changed in the field of law. Thanks in large part to affirmative action policies implemented since the mid-1960s, what used to be a strictly white, male-dominated profession, has become markedly more diverse. Today, according to the U.S. Census, close to half of all law school graduates are women, and minorities make up almost twenty percent of all recent graduates.

Nevertheless, a closer look at the figures reveals a more troubling picture—particularly regarding Hispanics and Latinas. As the 2000 Census reports, Hispanic women make up a mere 1.2 percent of all practicing lawyers in the United States (and Hispanics of both genders make up only 3.3 percent).
What to make of these statistics? Although they seem discouraging at first, numbers alone can never tell the whole story. The best way to understand the challenges and opportunities that meet Latinas in the law is by looking closely at the lives and experiences of actual Latina lawyers such as Mari Carmen Aponte, Margaret Montoya, Linda Madrid, Maritza Ryan, Nina Perales, Brigida Benitez, and Christina Sarchio.

Linda Madrid

Christina Sarchio

Mari Carmen Aponte

As a young teacher in a New Jersey, Puerto Rican community in the ’70s, Mari Carmen Aponte was struck by the inequality at the local schools. “I thought that there had to be a systemic remedy,” she says. So when Nelson Diaz, a local community organizer and the first Puerto Rican to practice law in Pennsylvania, suggested she apply to law school, she jumped at the chance. She applied and was accepted to Temple University Law School, as part of a special affirmative action program.
As one of a tiny number of Latinas in law school during the ’70s, Aponte felt she had to work extra hard to prove herself. “There were no safeguards—it was sink or swim,” she says. A small network of other minority students and some dedicated professors helped her get through the grueling classes. “I always somehow seemed to find support.”
During her very first case as a student lawyer, Aponte says, the judge told her that “people like her” should be at home instead of in the courts. But Aponte won the case and was even congratulated by the judge afterwards. “After that, no matter what they threw at me, I felt I could handle it.”
After winning a prestigious White House Fellowship, she began a three-decade career as a lawyer and legal consultant. Throughout that time, Aponte worked long hours. “I never married or had children, because I felt that that was not an option that I had,” she says. Nevertheless, she is happy when she reflects on how things have changed for Latinas in the law: “The women that came behind me feel that they have options, and that’s the way it should be.”
Margaret Montoya also began her career in the ’70s. As a college student in California, she was active in the Chicano and antiwar movements. “I really saw that understanding how to use the rules really helped in achieving objectives,” she says. She became the first Latina to attend law school at Harvard University.
At Harvard, Montoya faced a variety of challenges from non-minority students opposed to affirmative action. “It was just incendiary, with students telling us that they were intellectually superior, and that we had taken the place of people who should have been there,” she remembers.
Today, as a professor at the University of New Mexico School of Law, Montoya teaches her students about the legacy of affirmative action. “If they are beneficiaries of affirmative action, they have the responsibility to pay it back so that others can follow in their footsteps,” she says.
Linda Madrid, managing director, general counsel, and corporate secretary at CarrAmerica Realty Corporation, is paving the way in the world of business. As the chief compliance and ethics officer at her company, she is responsible for ensuring that the board and senior officers run things both legally and ethically. “To be a good lawyer, you have to have the highest of ethics,” she says. “You have to be able to sort out the wheat from the chaff, the truth from lies, the relevant from the irrelevant—both in facts and in laws.”

Brigida Benitez

Margaret Montoya.
Photo by Vangie Samora.

From left to right: Maritza Ryan and Justice Sandra Day O'Connor.

Madrid is excited about the changes that she’s seen since she started her career in the mid ’80s. “When I came out of law school, women particularly felt they had to make a choice” between work and children, she says. “Now there are dialogues taking place on a monthly basis with managing partners of law firms who are saying, ‘We need to figure out how to change the practice of law so it can be a place where women will stay.’”
Since she was a young girl, Col. Maritza Ryan had a legal career in mind. “I did forensics in high school, as well as drama—which probably didn’t hurt in the courtroom!” she says. After graduating from West Point and serving as a military officer for several years, she found out about the Judge Advocate General’s Funded Legal Education Program, a scholarship open to regular Army officers. Under that program, the Army sponsored her degree at Vanderbilt University Law School and subsequently put her through the Judge Advocate General’s Corps basic training.

< 1 2 >

By Julia Young


[This article has been edited for www.latinastyle.com. For the full version, check out the March/April issue of LATINA Style.]

Comments - Suggestions - Questions about this article please send us your feedback